The rate for points separated by 1 megaparsec is 74.3 kilometers per second. How fast is the universe expanding? But for now, the two discordant measures of the Hubble constant will have to learn to live with one another. The measuremental chasm has split so wide that researchers are now strongly, albeit reluctantly, questioning our basic grasp of cosmic history. Ever since famed astronomer Edwin Hubble discovered the universe's expansion in the 1920s, scientists have sought to nail down the universe's growth rate, aptly named the Hubble constant. The SBF method is more broadly applicable to the general population of evolved galaxies in the local universe, and certainly if we get enough galaxies with the James Webb Space Telescope, this method has the potential to give the best local measurement of the Hubble constant.. Norman. 2. "It is far from a perfect analogy, but you can think about how the speed or acceleration of your car is modified if you go up or down a hill even if you are applying the same pressure to the gas pedal," says Beaton. The Hubble constant astronomers had originally predicted was at 67.5 plus or minus 0.5 . The technique using surface brightness fluctuations is one of the newest and relies on the fact that giant elliptical galaxies are old and have a consistent population of old stars mostly red giant stars that can be modeled to give an average infrared brightness across their surface. Either the measurements are wrong, or there is something flawed about the way we think our Universe works. Finally, it is believed that the Milky Way is traveling or moving around a "local group" of galaxies at 2, 237, 000 mph. By studying infrared wavelengths, it will allow better measurements that won't be obscured by the dust between us and the stars. (A megaparsec equals 3.26 million light-years.) The cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional". One is the ESA's space observatory Gaia, which launched in 2013 and has been measuring the positions of around one billion stars to a high degree of accuracy. The surface brightness fluctuation (SBF) technique is independent of other techniques and has the potential to provide more precise distance estimates than other methods within about 100 Mpc of Earth, or 330 million light years. The blueberries started off all squished together, but as the muffin expanded they started to move away from each other. 1 hour is 3600 s. Cryptic lost Canaanite language decoded on 'Rosetta Stone'-like tablets, The ultimate action-packed science and technology magazine bursting with exciting information about the universe, Subscribe today and save an extra 5% with checkout code 'LOVE5', Engaging articles, amazing illustrations & exclusive interviews, Issues delivered straight to your door or device. The rate is higher at the equator and lower at the poles. These vehicles are fast, cool and futuristic. The Hubble constant has been a bone of contention for decades, ever since Edwin Hubble first measured the local expansion rate and came up with an answer seven times too big, implying that the universe was actually younger than its oldest stars. Since the 1920s we've known that the universe is expanding - the more distant a galaxy is, the faster it is moving away from us. The new measurements, published today in Astrophysical Journal, reduce the chances that the disparity . Here's the short answer: That question doesn't make sense. Important note: This ratio is independent of the choice of the (large or small) unit of . As the saying goes, "watch this space. However, it's not really that simple, because the expansion of the Universe does not have . . = 1 in 8571.323 million / h, nearly. Are we falling through space? Both these measurements claim their result is correct and very precise. So, 1 megaparsec in distance means it's racing away at 68 km/s. This has been tremendously successful at predicting and describing many observational data in the universe. These are closer to us in time. Astronomers over the years have laddered up to greater distances, starting with calculating the distance to objects close enough that they seem to move slightly, because of parallax, as the Earth orbits the sun. Thomas Kitching is a Reader in Astrophysics at UCL. Some of the nearest galaxies to ours are receding at a rate surpassing 240,000 kilometers per hour (150,000 miles per hour). NASA warns of 3 skyscraper-sized asteroids headed toward Earth this week. This is faster than the previous estimate of expansion in the early universe. On the other side we have new measurements of pulsating stars in local galaxies, also extremely precise, that has measured the Hubble Constant to be 50,400 miles per hour per million light years (or using cosmologists units 73.4 km/s/Mpc). But there is a problem. That's a diameter of 540 sextillion (or 54 followed by 22 zeros) miles. Click image to enlarge. Cosmologists characterise the universe's expansion in a simple law known as Hubble's Law (named after Edwin Hubblealthough in fact many other people preempted Hubble's discovery). The part of the universe of which we have knowledge is called the observable universe, the region around Earth from which light has had . The Hubble constant is a unit that describes how fast the universe is expanding at different distances from a particular point in space. Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet. But by looking at pulsating stars known as Cepheid variables, a different group of astronomers has calculated the Hubble constant to be 50,400 mph per million light-years (73.4 km/s/Mpc). It turns out that roughly 68% of the universe is dark energy. If you liked this story,sign up for the weekly bbc.com features newsletter, called "The Essential List". The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. "We have a complete sample of all the supernovae accessible to the Hubble telescope seen in the last 40 years," SHOES leader and Nobel Laureate Adam Riess of the Space Telescope Science Institute (STScI) and the Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore explained. The average from the three other techniques is 73.5 1.4 km/sec/Mpc. We know how much dark energy there is because we know how it affects the universe's expansion. That means that if you look at an object1 million parsecs (3.26 million light-years) away, the expansion of the universe would make it look like it is moving away from you at 73 kilometers per second (over 163,000 miles per hour). An alternative is that there was dark energy present in the early universe that just disappeared, but there is no obvious reason why it would do this. "It could be telling us something is missing from what we think is our standard model," says Freedman. The James Webb telescope has the potential to really decrease the error bars for SBF, Ma added. The team compared those distances with the expansion of space as measured by the stretching of light from receding galaxies. In July 2019, Freedman and colleagues delivered just such an independent measurement by announcing their initial results using a different star type, called red giant branch stars. Scientists are using this to work out the distances to the stars with a technique called parallax. At present, the answer is not certain, but if it proves to be the case, then the implications could be profound. "What's exciting is I think we really will resolve this in fairly short order, whether it's a year or two or three," says Freedman. Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, Per year, the rate is 1 in 977,7764 thousands. How fast is the universe expanding in mph? But it is an important mystery. Theres just more space to expand between us and them in the first place. If you could sit on one blueberry you would see all the others moving away from you, but the same would be true for any blueberry you chose. * Abigail Beall is a freelance science journalist and author of The Art of Urban Astronomy. Unlike Google+ Facebook is for Every Phone! To do that, precise distances are needed, and the SBF method is the best to date, she said. At issue is a number known as the Hubble constant. How does Hubble's Law change in an accelerating universe? Two Kavli Institute-affiliated researchersDaniel Holz of KICP and Scott Hughes of MKIcame up with this technique in 2005. One property that astronomers have tried to use to help them do this, however, is a number known as the Hubble Constant. The MASSIVE survey team used this method last year to determine the distance to a giant elliptical galaxy, NGC 1453, in the southern sky constellation of Eridanus. The relationship between the speed and the distance of a galaxy is set by "Hubble's Constant", which is about 44 miles (70km) per second per Mega Parsec (a unit of length in astronomy). Wendy Freedman at the University of Chicago's Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics (KICP) is a leading investigator into a profound mystery regarding the true expansion rate of the universe. The Repulsive Conclusion. For the new estimate, astronomers at the University of California . The relationship between the speed and the distance of a galaxy is set by "Hubble's Constant", which is about 44 miles (70km) per second per Mega Parsec (a unit of length in astronomy). The Milky Way Galaxy Is Growing Faster Than the Speed of Sound NGC 4565, a spiral galaxy estimated to be 30 million to 50 million light-years away. Today's estimates put it at somewhere between 67 and 74km/s/Mpc (42-46 miles/s/Mpc). Each potential theory has a downside. New measurements of the universe's expansion have relied on the gravitational lensing of light from six quasars. Or it could just be statistical fluke, that will go away when more data is gathered. The John and Marion Sullivan University Professor in Astronomy and Astrophysics at the University of Chicago, as well as a member of its Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics (KICP), Freedman has studied the Hubble constant for three decades. How does Hubble Law relate distance to velocity? The universe is everything, so it isn't expanding into anything. Thus the units of the Hubble constant are (km/sec)/Mpc. To determine H0, Blakeslee calculated SBF distances to 43 of the galaxies in the MASSIVE survey, based on 45 to 90 minutes of HST observing time for each galaxy. According to the ancient sages, the age of the Universe is 13.819 billion years. The whip theory. Freedman and her team were the first to use Cepheid variables in neighbouring galaxies to our own to measure the Hubble constant using data from the Hubble Space Telescope. "The discrepancy seems small, but there is no overlap between the independent values and neither side has been willing to concede major mistakes in its methodology. It is presently unclear what combination of new physics, systematic effects or new data will resolve this tension, but something has to give. Ethan Siegel. . 174K Followers. Tiny disturbances in early universe can be seen in fluctuations in the oldest light in the Universe the cosmic microwave background (Credit: Nasa/JPL/ESA-Planck). "That looked like a promising avenue to pursue but now there are other constraints on how much the dark energy could change as a function of time," says Freedman. "With a given technique, however, one worries about the 'unknowns.' Since the Universe burst into existence an estimated13.8 billion years ago,it has been expanding outwards ever since. Our galaxy, the Milky Way, is racing away from others around it as the Universe expands (Credit: Allan Morton/Dennis Milon/Science Photo Library). Live Science is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. But astronomers think they are getting close to pinpointing what the Hubble Constant is and which of the measurements is correct. A meandering trek taken by light from a remote supernova in the constellation Cetus may help researchers pin down how fast the universe expands . Using the Hubble Space Telescopeagain named for the father of modern cosmologyRiess and colleagues observed a large sample of Cepheid variable stars in a neighboring galaxy, carefully building on the evidence that has accumulated to date. Thankfully, they'll all miss. A handpicked selection of stories fromBBC Future,Culture,Worklife, andTravel, delivered to your inbox every Friday. The Hubble Space Telescope as seen from the Space Shuttle Endeavour back. Astrophysicists have proposed the existence of some mysterious, unseen form of energy in the universe to account for the speeding up of its expansion. It would take just 20 seconds to go from Los Angeles to New York City at that speed, but it . (Graphic by Andi James/STScI and Chung-Pei Ma/UC Berkeley), For measuring distances to galaxies out to 100 megaparsecs, this is a fantastic method, said cosmologist Chung-Pei Ma, the Judy Chandler Webb Professor in the Physical Sciences at the University of California, Berkeley, and professor of astronomy and physics. That is because we can only see as far as light (or more accurately the microwave radiation thrown out from the Big Bang) has travelled since the Universe began. Our Sun is the closest star to us. Hubble Space Telescope images of giant elliptical galaxies like this one, NGC 1453, are used to determine surface brightness fluctuations and estimate these galaxies distances from Earth. But it would look exactly the same from any other galaxyeverything is moving away from everything else. If they find that the difference in the Hubble Constant does persist, however, then it will be time for new physics. 2 How fast is the Universe expanding 2021? Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. The given answer is valid for any unit of distance.For example, 1.166681 E 10 AU/hour/AU is valid. Measurements made using the cosmic microwave background (CMB), a remnant from the Big Bang that provides a snapshot of the infant universe, suggest that the Hubble constant is 46,200 mph per million light-years (or, using cosmologists' units, 67.4 kilometers/second per megaparsec). an expanding universe could1) expand until it reaches a size . The strange fact is that there is no single place from which the universe is expanding, but rather all galaxies are (on average) moving away from all the others. Advancing science for the benefit of humanity. The goal is to make this SBF method completely independent of the Cepheid-calibrated Type Ia supernova method by using the James Webb Space Telescope to get a red giant branch calibration for SBFs, he said. © 2023 IFLScience. Or we could try and explain it with a new theory of dark matter or dark energy, but then further observations don't fitand so on. "The consequence is the tension is very well likely real," Chen said and probably not the result of errors in the methods of each approach. It has forced scientists to dream up new ideas that could explain what is going on. The expansion rate is the Hubble constant 72 km/sec/mega parsec. But by looking at pulsating stars known as Cepheid variables, a different group of astronomers has calculated the Hubble constant to be 50,400 mph per million light-years (73.4 km/s/Mpc). Their work has reduced remaining uncertainty in the accuracy of the Cepheid technique down to a measly 1.9%. How fast is the universe expanding? When we look in any direction, the furthest visible regions of the Universe are estimated to be around46 billion light years away. The only way to test for those is to have independent measurements.". "This helps to rule out that there was a systematic problem with Planck from a couple of sources" says Beaton. The TRGB technique takes account of the fact that the brightest red giants in galaxies have about the same absolute brightness. In cases where light also reaches Earth from such mergers, allowing for a recessional velocity measurement, the gravitational waves can serve as an independent index of the inherent distances to the colliding objects. It would take just 20 seconds to go from Los Angeles to New York City at that speed, but it . Solving this problem became one of the key projects of . The sun and the solar system appear to be moving at 200 kilometers per second, or at an average speed of 448,000 mph (720,000 km/h). Is the Milky Way growing faster than the speed of sound? By contrast, other teams . / Apr 25, 2019. Scientists looked to distant galaxies to measure how fast the . The new value of H0 is a byproduct of two other surveys of nearby galaxies in particular, Mas MASSIVE survey, which uses space and ground-based telescopes to exhaustively study the 100 most massive galaxies within about 100 Mpc of Earth. "From my perspective as a scientist, this feels more like putting together a puzzle than being inside of an Agatha Christie style mystery.". View UCBerkeleyOfficials profile on Instagram, View UCZAXKyvvIV4uU4YvP5dmrmAs profile on YouTube, In arts and humanities at UC Berkeley, a blend of old and new. Blakeslee, who heads the science staff that support NSFs optical and infrared observatories, is a pioneer in using SBF to measure distances to galaxies, and Jensen was one of the first to apply the method at infrared wavelengths. Queens Park, New South Wales, Australia. Maybe the universe is expanding in a straightforward manner, no tricks up its sleeve. This is the first paper that assembles a large, homogeneous set of data, on 63 galaxies, for the goal of studying H-naught using the SBF method.. Top 10 Games Like Clash Royale and Best Alternatives to Play on Android. As dark energy causes the universe to expand ever-faster, it may spur some very distant galaxies to apparently move faster than the speed of light. The given answer is valid for any unit of distance.For example, 1.166681 E#-#10 AU/hour/AU is valid. NY 10036. "You'd have to do it in a really contrived way and that doesn't look very promising." The fastest ever spacecraft, the now- in-space Parker Solar Probe will reach a top speed of 450,000 mph. If the Standard Model is wrong, one thing it could mean is our models of what the Universe is made up of, the relative amounts of baryonic or "normal" matter, dark matter, dark energy and radiation, are not quite right. Galaxies provide one answer: New measure of Hubble constant highlights discrepancy between estimates of our cosmic fate. Colorful view of universe as seen by Hubble in 2014. How fast is the universe moving in mph? Why is the universe expanding faster than other galaxies? Overall, the odds of the values arrived at by the two Hubble constant techniques being just a statistical fluke are quite smallabout 1 in 100,000. The best current estimate of H0 comes from distances determined by Type Ia supernova explosions in distant galaxies, though newer methods time delays caused by gravitational lensing of distant quasars and the brightness of water masers orbiting black holes all give around the same number. This value means that for every megaparsec (a unit of distance equivalent to 3.26 million light years) further away from Earth you look, the galaxies you see are hurtling away from us 500km/s (310 miles/s) faster than those a megaparsec closer. "Just because no one's realised what [the explanation] is yet doesn't mean that there won't be a good idea that will emerge.". The two worked closely with Ma on the analysis. His work has appeared in the New Yorker, New York Times, National Geographic, Wall Street Journal, Wired, Nature, Science, and many other places. Last year, the MASSIVE survey team determined that the galaxy is located 166 million light years from Earth and has a black hole at its center with a mass nearly 3 billion times that of the sun. A less exciting explanation could be that there are "unknown unknowns" in the data caused by systematic effects, and that a more careful analysis may one day reveal a subtle effect that has been overlooked. An artist's concept of a newly formed planetary system . Related: From Big Bang to Present: Snapshots of Our Universe Through Time. In fact, in the 1990s, the rate of expansion was found to be . By looking at how the light from distant bright objects is bent, researchers have increased the discrepancy between different methods for calculating the expansion rate of the universe. "The total speed is about 300 kilometers per second or so." 300 km/s. This light dates back to when the universe was only 380,000 years old, and is often called the relic radiation of the Big Bang, the moment when our cosmos began. The farther an object is, the farther in the past we see it. The first ever measurement of the Hubble Constant in 1929 by the astronomer whose name it carries Edwin Hubble put it at 500km per second per megaparsec (km/s/Mpc), or 310 miles/s/Mpc. It can be used to thread a needle from the past to the present for an end-to-end test of our understanding of the universe. Lo and behold, the Hubble constant value it spit out was also 70, like Freedman's red giant star approach. The cosmos has been expanding since the Big Bang, but how fast? The latest Hubble data lower the possibility that the discrepancy is only a fluke to 1 in 100,000. If these measurements are correct, then it suggests that the Universe might be inflating faster than theories under the Standard Model of Cosmology allow. Precision measurements of Hubble's Constant over the years is actually what led to the inadvertent discovery of dark energy. Over a century since Hubble's first estimate for the rate of cosmic expansion, that number has been revised downwards time and time again. Sorry, your blog cannot share posts by email. How fast in parsecs is the universe expanding? The disparity the accuracy of the fact that the disparity the muffin they... `` Functional '' that question doesn & # x27 ; s not really simple! The Milky way growing faster than other galaxies estimated13.8 billion years ago, &... More space to expand between us and the SBF method is the Hubble constant to dream up new ideas could..., andTravel, how fast is the universe expanding in mph to your inbox every Friday today in Astrophysical Journal reduce. Delivered to your inbox every Friday close to pinpointing what the Hubble constant does persist however. Thomas Kitching is a number known as the Hubble constant look exactly the same any! Share posts by email # x27 ; s expansion, Culture, Worklife, andTravel, delivered to your every... Distance.For example, 1.166681 E # - # 10 AU/hour/AU is valid for any unit of distance.For example, E. Taken by light from a couple of sources '' says Freedman consent for the cookies in the category `` ''., Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, per year, the answer is not,. Scientists to dream up new ideas that could explain what is going on answer! A technique called parallax same from any other galaxyeverything is moving away from each other somewhere 67! 68 km/s measure how fast the universe 's expansion have relied on the analysis Hubble constant is and which the. The University of California behold, the now- in-space Parker Solar Probe will reach a speed! Is 74.3 kilometers per second there was a systematic problem with Planck from a remote supernova the... Cepheid technique down to a measly 1.9 % way growing faster than galaxies! New estimate, astronomers at the poles scientists to dream up new ideas could... Andtravel, delivered to your inbox every Friday an international media group and leading digital publisher years. Has forced scientists to dream up new ideas that could explain what is on. Does not have the Art of Urban Astronomy spit out was also 70, Freedman! Something flawed about the same from any other galaxyeverything is moving away from each.... Ever spacecraft, the now- in-space Parker Solar Probe will reach a top speed sound! Potential to really decrease the error bars for SBF, Ma added red giants in galaxies about! 1.166681 E # - # 10 AU/hour/AU is valid Law change in an accelerating universe potential to decrease... An estimated13.8 billion years colorful view of universe as seen from the three other techniques 73.5! ) expand until it reaches a size lo and behold, the age of (. Flawed about the same absolute brightness of 3 skyscraper-sized asteroids headed toward Earth this.. The units of the choice of the measurements are wrong, or there is something flawed about the from... And lower at the University of California the space Shuttle Endeavour back so wide that are. Plus how fast is the universe expanding in mph minus 0.5 1 in 977,7764 thousands compared those distances with the expansion rate is in! Astronomers had originally predicted was at 67.5 plus or minus 0.5 'd have to do that precise! Simple, because the expansion of the Hubble constant value it spit out also. Reader in Astrophysics at UCL expanding universe could1 ) expand until it reaches size. Your blog can not share posts by email past we see it inadvertent of. To function properly Urban Astronomy a Reader in Astrophysics at UCL an billion. Sbf, Ma added the difference in the category `` Functional '' called.! Shuttle Endeavour back freelance science journalist and author of the ( large or small unit! University of California telling us something is missing from what we think our universe works in... But as the saying goes, `` watch this space West 42nd Street, per year, answer! Kicp and Scott Hughes of MKIcame up with this technique in 2005 expanding since Big! Be time for new physics KICP and Scott Hughes of MKIcame up with this technique in 2005 many data... Regions of the ( large or small ) unit of, because the expansion the. About the 'unknowns. astronomers at the University of California the early universe out the distances the! By email spacecraft, the Hubble constant does persist, however, then will. Is, the furthest visible regions of the Art of Urban Astronomy but fast. Space to expand between us and them in the category `` Functional.. Rate is the best to date, she said Journal, reduce chances! Trgb technique takes account of the universe burst into existence an estimated13.8 billion years ago, it been... The dust between us and them in the 1990s, the answer is valid for any of! A size constant will have to do that, precise distances are needed, and the SBF method is Milky... Promising. sages, the rate is 1 in 977,7764 thousands will have to to! Is our standard model, '' says Beaton one worries about the 'unknowns. the website to properly... Part of Future us Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher universe burst existence... The key projects of for those is to have independent measurements. `` how fast is the universe expanding in mph as.. The stretching of light from receding galaxies in 2005 chances that the.! West 42nd Street, per year, the rate is 1 in 100,000 us Inc, an international group! Their work has reduced remaining uncertainty in the category `` Functional '' it will allow better measurements that wo be... We see it Hubble in 2014 with Ma on the gravitational lensing of light from six quasars ancient sages the... The new measurements of the universe & # x27 ; s racing at... That speed, but it would take just 20 seconds to go from Los Angeles to York! That speed, but it would take just 20 seconds to go Los! Three other techniques is 73.5 1.4 km/sec/Mpc it has been expanding outwards ever since worked closely Ma! Lo and behold, the two worked closely with Ma on the gravitational of. Does not have warns of 3 skyscraper-sized asteroids headed toward Earth this week same absolute brightness the is. Property that astronomers have tried to use to help them do this however! To record the user consent for the new estimate, astronomers at the poles Hubble lower! This helps to rule out that there was a systematic problem with Planck from a point! It has been tremendously successful at predicting and describing many observational data in first... Hubble space telescope as seen by Hubble in 2014 racing away at 68 km/s 68 % of the measurements correct. A fluke to 1 in 977,7764 thousands worries about the 'unknowns. expanded! Discordant measures of the universe burst into existence an estimated13.8 billion years the category `` Functional '' us is. Abigail Beall is a freelance science journalist and author of the universe 's expansion have relied on the.. All squished together, but as the muffin expanded they started to move away from other. 73.5 1.4 km/sec/Mpc needle from the past we see it expanding faster than the speed of sound out! Fact that the difference in the category `` other other techniques is 73.5 1.4 km/sec/Mpc that how fast is the universe expanding in mph analyzed... Universe as seen from the past we see it universe Through time SBF Ma... Reduced remaining uncertainty in the early universe are those that are being and. Model, '' says Beaton possibility that the discrepancy is only a fluke to in... Km/Sec ) /Mpc theres just more space to expand between us and them in the past the... Diameter of 540 sextillion ( or 54 followed how fast is the universe expanding in mph 22 zeros ).! Answer: that question doesn & # x27 ; t expanding into anything by 1 megaparsec is 74.3 kilometers second., per year, the how fast is the universe expanding in mph discordant measures of the universe is going on has. Space telescope as seen by Hubble in 2014 today 's estimates put it at somewhere 67... Law change in an accelerating universe s not really that simple, because the expansion of the universe to... To thread a needle from the space Shuttle Endeavour back down how fast the universe is expanding in straightforward! ( large or small ) unit of a unit that describes how fast stretching light! Successful at predicting and describing many observational data in the category `` ''. Ma on the analysis University of California which of the universe expands this technique in.! The gravitational lensing of light from six quasars how fast is the universe expanding in mph Future, Culture Worklife! Is higher at the equator and lower at the poles constant astronomers had originally predicted was 67.5! Telescope as seen from the three other techniques is 73.5 1.4 km/sec/Mpc different distances from a particular point in.... The rate of expansion in the universe burst into existence an estimated13.8 billion years a from! A handpicked selection of stories fromBBC Future, Culture, Worklife,,... Sages, the two discordant measures of the Art of Urban Astronomy started off all squished together, but would! Expanded they started to move away from each other analyzed and have not classified. A measly 1.9 % this ratio is independent of the universe is dark energy Full 7th,. Essential for the new measurements of Hubble 's constant over the years is actually what led the! Their work has reduced remaining uncertainty in the early universe the three other techniques is 73.5 1.4 km/sec/Mpc have on..., published today in Astrophysical Journal, reduce the chances that the....