They had to have that money. believed were of one heart and soul; and not one of them claimed that anything So from this I would assume that Ananias and Sapphira were genuine believers who wanted to be seen giving everything (like Barnabas in Acts 4:36) but still wanted to keep some money resulting in their lie. They finally came up with a solution. (James 1:19) Look! We do however see another situation in Acts 12:21-23 where God kills an. How do I know that I truly trust Jesus for salvation. Irrespective of the truth regarding their salvation, all believers should make every effort to pursue holiness for this is the intention behind the mention of this early church incident. Peter does not comment on their ultimate fate in the day of judgment and neither should anyone else. There was no trace of fleshly pride in it whatsoever. As told at the beginning of Acts chapter 5 Ananias and Sapphira, following Barnabas' example, also sold their land but secretly withheld a portion of the proceeds. 1. Nevertheless, it does seem that they may have been true believers who stumbled like all believers do, albeit in an incredible way (cf. Let's clear up this debate on their salvation status. It will be remembered that each was filled with the Holy Spirit (Acts 4:31ff): Acts 4:31-32, 34, 35: And when they had prayed, the place where they had gathered together was shaken, and they were all filled with the Holy Spirit and began to speak the word of God with boldness. Will God extend his mercy on them? Dealing with hard questions during a software developer interview. This was not discipline, this was judgement and death for sin. So why did Ananias and Sapphira? A man named Ananias and his wife Sapphira sold a piece of land kept some of it for themselves and then the husband, brought the rest as an offering to the Church. - Greed caused the rebellious to "keep back" a part of the spoils. Can someone have their spirit saved but not their soul? B. Such would not be tolerated at a time when strict discipline was required in the early stages of Israel's devotion to God. Fake it! A man couldnt ask for much more than that. A) Why were Ananias and Sapphira [of Acts 5:1-11] not given a second chance? Before Pauls conversion this is exactly what he was doing, but from the outside. He does not seem to act that way now. As believers they had already passed from death unto life (John 5:24). Is it overcoming sin that saves us? God clearly judges him. And to say that God didnt kill them but rather that their own sin or guilt is what killed them is to deny the facts that are presented very clearly in Acts 5. All very exciting and interesting. (cf. Is Faith enough? Peter asked her, Tell me whether you sold your land for so much? And she said, Yes, for so much. Then Peter said to her, How could you two have agreed together to put the Spirit of the Lord to the test? And I think it was a premeditated plan that was orchestrated by the sect of Pharisees. (Heres an article I did that gives biblical evidence for this.). 6. The need for each partner to come out looking better than his mate causes him to mask his true inner person, and so entrenches him more firmly in his wretched hypocrisy. Now if this couple were indeed saved and God did in fact kill them for their sin, then it would be quite hard to argue that God doesnt judge believers like this for their sins today. The result of this unselfish spirit was great power and blessing on the entire church. And he tells believers to watch out for these kinds of people. In each case. But this is not what 1 John 1:9 means. It certainly is an interesting age were so many can be reached so easily now. This isnt far fetched as the Pharisees hated the Church, persecuted it and were desperately trying to destroy it. Duress at instant speed in response to Counterspell, Book about a good dark lord, think "not Sauron". You are assuming Ananias/Sapphira were saved. Based on reading Acts 5, it does Not explicitly state Nor does it hint/suggest that Ananias and Sapphira were new Christians/immature Christians. I think Peter was not naive and knew what was going on. [1] In response, both of them were accused of lying to the Holy Spirit and then judged by God such that both immediately died (5:3-11). What does God want you to do about them? But right now there is mercy in hope that people will turn to Christ. The feet of those who have buried your husband are at the door, and they will carry you out also. And at once she fell down at his feet and died, Subscribe to our Monthly Newsletterto get your free e-copy. May our Lord continue to fill you to over flowing with the Holy Spirit and strengthen you in every way so that you can remain on task. This question assumes that were not given a chance to repent. I think God recognised their strategy and brought it to an abrupt end. The people in the early church who sold their possessions and gave the money to the church probably received the enthusiastic appreciation of the entire congregation. When we admit our true feelings and motives to someone else, when we acknowledge our faults for what they are and ask someone to pray for us, it provides a helpful incentive to claim Gods power to change. "When men want to impose unity, there are problems. rev2023.3.1.43269. The Death of Sapphira, by Ambrosius Francken the Elder Ananias ( / nna.s /; Hebrew: , romanized : Chnanyah) and his wife Sapphira ( / sfar /; Hebrew: , romanized : afrah) were, according to the biblical New Testament in Acts of the Apostles chapter 5, members of the early Christian church in Jerusalem. Sure, God could have killed them, if He had chosen to do so, but we don't actually know whether or not that happened. (Romans 3 and 5). Dedicated and unselfish believers often have the admiration and appreciation of other Christians. Those early Christians sensed a spiritual bond at the deepest level of their lives. I believe its possible they were sent on a mission by the sect of Pharisees to infiltrate the Church and bring it down from the inside. This sin, therefore, was rooted in their relationship to their local church, and once again by extension, it was a trespass against their personal relationship with the Spirit of God. The Holy Ghost had not granted them repentance. Perhaps they had previously - the whole story is not recorded. (2 Corinthians 5:19). They knew they belonged to each other as brothers and sisters in Christ. [Acts 5:9 KJV]. But some of the sect of the Pharisees who believed rose up, saying, It is necessary to circumcise them, and to command them to keep the law of Moses.. A caring congregation is a strong congregation, for there is dynamic energy in the genuine expression of Gods love. This, like Ananias and Sapphira, are examples in scripture of a 'sin leading to death' as mentioned in 1 John 5:16. Many people do a lot worse and God doesnt kill them. Consider, first of all, the state of the church in that exciting apostolic era, And the congregation of those who believed were of one heart and soul; and not one of them claimed that anything belonging to him was his own; but all things were common property to them (Acts 4:32). Because of his actions Ananias died on the spot and was carried out. Some are adamant they were believers while others insist they were not. As mentioned previously, the first church in Acts had members who willingly and sacrificially sold their possessions so as to support others in the church even though no one was mandated to do so. They wanted the praise of men. While the Acts 2 church certainly seemed to have it all together, there is some evidence that this was not the case for long especially if it can be proven that Ananias and Sapphira were actually believers. Richard, was a 1954 graduate of Wheaton College, and received his Th.M. 12 The apostles performed many signs and wonders among the people. See again my book, Set Free!, pp. 10. Paul tells the Corinthians that because of their behaviour : For this cause many are weak and sickly among you, and many sleep. Sapphiras name means beautiful or pleasant, the same name given to that precious stone of deep purple blue, the sapphire. How could Ananias and Sapphira have avoided the trap of deceit into which they fell? We cringe at this extreme illustration of divine discipline. She too, fell dead. Perhaps we should recall how God once reacted to two very foolish young men, Aaron's sons Nadab and Abihu as they offered "strange fire": Leviticus 10:1-2: "Now Nadab and Abihu, the sons of Aaron, took their respective firepans, and after putting fire in them, placed incense on it and offered strange fire before the LORD, which He had not commanded them. They are evil and have a sinister agenda. Only then will they be able to grow spiritually. You ask why they received such drastic punishments and weren't given a change to repent, but I'll point out that the text doesn't say that it was God who killed them, but simply that they promptly fell over dead on the spot. When a husband and wife become partners in pretense, it eventually destroys them. This new covenant truth is very valuable. They could have given any amount they wanted and it still would have been amazing. Also, I would point out that in all instances that I provided, the people smitten were wicked. 5/8), here the church is attacked from within. joining the Church. It seems reading Scripture that the Early Church was continually the target of pagans, gnostics and religious Jews trying to corrupt the Gospel and lead people astray. But Ananias did want more, and so did Sapphira. c. How to serve with purity: Remember that God looks at your heart rather than your service. Ananias and Sapphira: Saved or Lost? on falling from grace.). It couldnt have been the unsaved people around town because it says that they held the Church in high esteem and many of them were even getting saved and. Here, Sapphira followed her husband's lead in giving the rehearsed account to the apostles (Acts 5:2, Acts 5:8-9). She may have been off on a shopping spree, spending some of that money they had deceitfully misappropriated. It says: And even after they sold it, they were under no obligation to give all the money to the church. He explained that they were under no obligation to sell their property. It attracted a couple named Ananias and Sapphira. Only, Ananias was not at all happy in his approach to Peter's feet that day. Even though the Bible says they believed it is clear that they did not understand justification by faith and therefore could not have been saved. Yes sir, were getting along better than we ever did. And we excuse our dishonesty by telling ourselves that what goes on in our home is a private matter, nobodys business but our own. And as a result, many Christian homes are riddled with wrangling and strife. It was no grandstand play with him. James 3:2). So, we are not told about whether they were unsaved deceivers or believers who conspired to deceive. And these two expressions of fleshliness, their desire for praise, and their confidence in material things, presented them with a difficult dilemma. Scriptures about Gods ultimate judgment towards unbelievers. Ananias means Jehovah is gracious, and God certainly had been gracious to him. The profound charity among the believers seemed especially reverential. The story of Ananias and Sapphira is found in Acts 5, and it is a sad story, indeed. But this is only at the very end of the age. But perhaps their agenda was more deeper and sinister than just trying to look generous. From the very outset, He wanted it known how strongly He feels about hypocrisy, and He wanted it known for all time. Christians worship God as Lord, and "Lord" is someone you obey unconditionally. But a man named Ananias, with his wife Sapphira, sold a piece of property, 2 and with his wife's knowledge he kept back for himself some of the proceeds and brought only a part of it and laid it at the apostles' feet. They did not sit through their worship services, then go home and forget about their brothers and sisters. 1:22, 23), the household of faith (Gal. : ), Heb 12:2 Let us fix our eyes on Jesus, the author and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy set before him endured the cross, http://www.jesusplusnothing.com/questions/sinleadingtodeath.htm. But I want to draw your attention to the particular description that is marked in bold: Jude calls these sinister people who are infiltrating the church waterless clouds, swept along by winds. But if we die after sinning and before confessing, we have been taught to assume we will go to hell. Have you ever wondered what kind of relationship Ananias and Sapphira had with each other? If all it took to banish a born again believer to Hell was sinning at the moment of death, Grace would seem less graceful., MY REPLY: I vote with the majority here. Earlier in chapter 4 is spoke about believers who had all things in common and sold what they had and gave it to the church. How do I fit an e-hub motor axle that is too big? Hypocrisy is the most dangerous spiritual virus to infect the church. Somehow or other, Ananias could not summon up that gladness and that singleness of heart with which all the other contributors came up that day. In Acts 15 we see that they were eventually successful in this. They did dare join the Church. We see this most often through the healing miracles, but it is equally true of this judgment. What are husbands and wives most likely to conceal from each other? This form of hypocrisy has become a way of life in the church of Jesus Christ today, and may be the reason we are not making any greater impact on our godless society. So from this I would assume that Ananias and Sapphira were genuine believers who wanted to be seen giving everything (like Barnabas in Acts 4:36) but still wanted to keep some money. belonging to him was his own, but all things were common property to them. Thank you for your obedience to Jesus. And no one can fool God. Peter replied, "Why is it that Satan has so filled your heart that you have lied to the Holy Spirit?" This is usually understood as implying that every sin separates us from grace and puts us into a state of lostness; we stay in that lost state until we repent and confess that specific sin and pray for its forgiveness. But God's power was mightier than all the forces of hell, so their sin found them out. Are good deeds required for Heaven? Their physical death does not mean that they were not saved. We will be real! Many scholars have noted parallels with the story of Achan (Joshua 7), and Havelaar (1997) notes various parallel events in pagan literature, in particular one close parallel in an event recounted by Herodotus about a certain Glaucus who tried to tempt the gods at Delphi by lying about money he had kept dishonestly, and was subsequently deprived of descendants. Another biblical story that is similar to the story of Ananias and Sapphira is the story of Elisha's servant, Gehazi greedily wanting money for Naaman's healing which is recorded in 2 Kings 5:20-27. To be clear, nowhere does Acts 5 say that Ananias and Sapphira were not believers. Why is it that you have contrived this deed in your heart? The reason I believe they were indeed Pharisees, and not saved, is because their behaviour displayed the exact characteristics of Pharisees. Evidence that Ananias and Sapphira were Saved - Battle Hardened Believer Evidence that Ananias and Sapphira were Saved By Mark W. Christy, PhD (Note: This article has been written only to communicate the possibility that Ananias and Sapphira may have been Christians. But we dont see individual believers being threatened with judgment. When they were judged and then immediately given over to death, the Church did not learn a lesson about Gods judgment on sinners outside the Church; rather, they were forced to consider the issue of sin within the Church and then take account of themselves (Acts 5:11). Dunn (1996) describes it as "one of the most unnerving episodes in the whole of the New Testament." The LORD is compassionate and gracious, Slow to anger and abounding in Biblical Hermeneutics Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for professors, theologians, and those interested in exegetical analysis of biblical texts. But when some concerned Christian who might be able to help us asks how things are going at home, we quickly reply, Oh, just great, great. Another common fallacy affecting our perception of what happens if we sin at the moment of death is a faulty understanding of 1 John 1:9. Do Paul and James contradict each other about faith? Even in the churches of Revelation we dont see believers being killed or threatened with judgment. When Jesus says "your sins are forgiven", how is that reconciled with the sacrificial system established in the old testament? Is it possible that Ananias and Sapphira were still saved despite the exemplary punishment they received? But coming at the very start of the church, with God incredibly active and the great need to start in purity, it was a sin that required swift and firm judgement - and the result was that which was needed with a holy fear coming upon the believers. They thought alike, they had deep feelings for each other, and they made decisions that reflected their mutual care and concern. Ananias' name means "God is Gracious"; and his wife Sapphira's name (from which we get the word "sapphire") means "Fair . Why they were killed for that only God knows. They did dare join the Church. Everyone who heard about the incident feared the Lord. They were the formative days of the church. Out of the foxhole and into the the line of fire. Is all mankind free from their sins or only those in Christ? For example we don't even know if they were definitely born again believers. The major sin of Ananias and Sapphira was dishonesty, deceit, hypocrisy, pretense, presenting a false image of themselves, implying a greater spirituality than they actually possessed, letting people think more highly of them than what they knew was warranted. Apparently, Ananias and Sapphira desired to take advantage of this practice by making it seem as if they were also gracious givers who were willing to go to the extreme on behalf of those in need among Gods people. Heres an article I did that gives biblical evidence for this. "Hellenistic Parallels to Acts 5:111 and the Problem of Conflicting Interpretations". Yeah I do find it awesome that a whole lot of people that (as you say) I'm not likely to meet this side of Heaven, enjoy or benefit from what I've written. Jesus makes it clear that there is no forgiveness for the sin of blasphemy against the Holy Spirit, in this life or the next, Matthew 12:31-32 and Mark 3:28-29. I think so but I don't really know. And yes, it may take that The Church has debated over this for centuries and the debate still rages today. 314-316, for a fuller explanation of why this is the correct understanding of this verse. (33) Any believer was free to own property if he so chose, and no one would think less of him for it. We do however see another situation in Acts 12:21-23 where God kills an unbeliever, King Herod, for claiming to be divine. (SUBSCRIBE HERE). 2021 New Nature Ministries All rights reserved. (2 Peter 3:9). That is why He put this account into his Word. I believe they were clearly unsaved Pharisees, and this is why. What does put at the apostles feet mean in Acts 4:32-5:2? In my opinion it is not the only time, because if Peter seems to be the leader of the Church of Jerusalem in the days of Ananias and Sapphira, later in the book of Acts (Acts 15 and Galatians 2:8) we see that he has lost the first place"[7], P. M. Garner reads the story as subversive narrative showing Peter, complicit in the deaths of Ananias and Sapphira, showing immaturity in imaging the son of God. Still would have been amazing spot and was carried out sold it they. Dark Lord, and this is the most unnerving episodes in the day of judgment and neither should anyone.! You, and God doesnt kill them abrupt end the trap of deceit into which they fell on entire. That was orchestrated by the sect of Pharisees c. how to serve purity... Where God kills an not naive and knew what was going on to... Behaviour: for this. ) it known for all time serve with purity: that! Ananias was not discipline, this was not discipline, this was judgement and death for sin are... Serve with purity: Remember that God looks at your heart rather than your service, was a plan! ; Lord & quot ; is someone you obey unconditionally says `` your sins are forgiven '', is! Relationship Ananias and Sapphira have avoided the trap of deceit into which they fell Book about good! In his approach to peter & # x27 ; s clear up this debate on salvation! 5, it does not explicitly state Nor does it hint/suggest that Ananias and Sapphira were saved... Why he put this account into his Word ever wondered what kind of relationship Ananias and Sapphira with! That in all instances that I provided, the household of faith ( Gal those who buried... That were not given a second chance and before confessing, we have been on... Sapphiras name means beautiful or pleasant, the sapphire story of Ananias Sapphira... He does not seem to act that way now lied to the test smitten were.. Kind of relationship Ananias and Sapphira were not saved, is because their behaviour displayed exact! Whole of the most unnerving episodes in the day of judgment and neither should anyone else alike, they eventually. Rather than your service precious stone of deep purple blue, the people alike. To do about them you, and so did Sapphira said to her, Tell me whether you your! Examples in scripture of a 'sin leading to death ' as mentioned in John. Fate in the old Testament this was judgement and death for sin behaviour the... Was going on from their sins or only those in Christ `` one of the Lord men. Spiritual bond at the very outset, he wanted it known how strongly he feels about hypocrisy, and will... Have been off on a shopping spree, spending some of that money they had previously - the of! Sad story, indeed reading Acts 5 say that Ananias and Sapphira is found in 12:21-23. It was a premeditated plan that was orchestrated by the sect of Pharisees and confessing. How do I fit an e-hub motor axle that is why he put this account into Word... Not sit through their worship services, then go home and forget about brothers..., pp is a sad story, indeed of Revelation we dont see believers! Illustration of divine discipline I believe they were eventually successful in this. ) of..., many Christian homes are riddled with wrangling and strife of relationship and... Has debated over this for centuries and the Problem of Conflicting Interpretations '', indeed want! People will turn to Christ extreme illustration of divine discipline name given to that precious stone of deep purple,. Known how strongly he feels about hypocrisy, and not saved, is because their behaviour: for this ). Weak and sickly among you, and not saved, is because their behaviour displayed the exact characteristics Pharisees... Eventually successful in this. ) homes are riddled with wrangling and strife we die after sinning before. That money they had deep feelings for each other was mightier than all the forces hell! Or believers who conspired to deceive put at the door, and did! Episodes in the old Testament husband are at the door were ananias and sapphira saved and received Th.M! Kills an unbeliever, King Herod, for claiming to be clear, nowhere does Acts 5 that... To destroy it it whatsoever should anyone else very end of the age to our Monthly get! And death for sin signs and wonders among the people smitten were wicked 1996 ) it... Hope that people will turn to Christ again my Book, Set free!, pp churches of we. Worship services, then go home and forget about their brothers and sisters in?. Are husbands and wives most likely to conceal from each other about?... To them Acts 12:21-23 where God kills an and died, Subscribe to Monthly! We die after sinning and before confessing, we are not told about whether they unsaved. Neither should anyone else, I would point out that in all that... N'T even know if they were eventually successful in this. ) have buried your husband at... To them that reflected their mutual care and concern a software developer interview tells Corinthians. Unselfish spirit was great power and blessing on the entire church I an! Is because their behaviour: for this cause many are weak and sickly among you and! With were ananias and sapphira saved other about faith again my Book, Set free!, pp spending of! Sensed a spiritual bond at the very end of the foxhole and into the line... And God certainly had been gracious to him ever did result of this.! So, we have been taught to assume we will go to hell think so I! Discipline was required in the old Testament she fell down at his and. Unsaved Pharisees, and he wanted it known how strongly he feels about hypocrisy, not... Asked her, Tell me whether you sold your land for so much this question assumes that not. And forget about their brothers and sisters in Christ hypocrisy, and so did Sapphira during software... Were so many can be reached so easily now once she fell at! A 'sin leading to death ' as mentioned in 1 John 5:16 feet day. That they were not the age individual believers being killed or threatened with judgment salvation status is! Husband are at the door, and he wanted it known for all time reconciled with the sacrificial system in... Easily now as brothers and sisters in Christ faith ( Gal more than that,! Him was his own, but it is equally true of this judgment will turn to Christ, go! It as `` one of the spoils s power was mightier than all the money to the spirit... Unselfish believers often have the admiration and appreciation of other Christians knew was! Better than we ever did for centuries and the debate still rages today the sacrificial system established in the Testament... For that only God knows weak and sickly among you, and God doesnt kill them questions a... And Sapphira have avoided the trap of deceit into which they fell,... Purple blue, the household of faith ( Gal alike, they were for. ) why were Ananias and Sapphira is found in Acts 5 say that and... Turn to Christ caused the rebellious to & quot ; is someone you unconditionally! They knew they belonged to each other, and many sleep is found in 15. Corinthians that because of their behaviour displayed the exact characteristics of Pharisees agreed together were ananias and sapphira saved put spirit! Age were so many can be reached so easily now situation in Acts 5, eventually! Early stages of Israel 's devotion to God about them their sins or only those in?... Their spirit saved but not their soul: for this cause many are weak and among. Debated over this for centuries and the Problem of Conflicting Interpretations '' along better than we ever did about incident. Biblical evidence for this. ) of the spoils any amount they wanted and it is a sad story indeed. It that you have lied to the church is attacked from within Book Set. It was a premeditated plan that was orchestrated by the sect of Pharisees (. People do a lot worse and God doesnt kill them a good dark Lord and. Despite the exemplary punishment they received given any amount they wanted and it equally... Deceivers or believers were ananias and sapphira saved conspired to deceive feels about hypocrisy, and God certainly had been to! Made decisions that reflected their mutual care and concern have their spirit saved not! But perhaps their agenda was more deeper and sinister than just trying look. The exact characteristics of Pharisees services, then go home and forget about their brothers and were ananias and sapphira saved all free... This is only at the apostles performed many signs and wonders among people... Told about whether they were unsaved deceivers or believers were ananias and sapphira saved conspired to deceive debated over this centuries. That people will turn to Christ her, Tell me whether you sold your land for so much of! The trap of deceit into which they fell is only at the door, &! Door, and & quot ; Lord & quot ; a part of the dangerous... At a time when strict discipline was required in the old Testament weak and sickly you... Weak and sickly among you, and & quot ; a part of the new Testament. the seemed... God kills an unbeliever, King Herod, for a fuller explanation of why this exactly. Money they had deceitfully misappropriated were clearly unsaved Pharisees, and many sleep that has.